Friday, January 1, 2010

Insulation vs. Air Leakage (Attic Bypasses)

With winter officially here, I’m on a big insulation kick.  This is the time of year when I can really tell which houses have attic problems, oftentimes just from looking at the house on the outside!  Today I’ll talk about a few things I look for when inspecting an attic when it comes to air leakage, insulation, and ventilation.

When I inspect houses in the winter, the first thing I look at is the roof.  I do this out of habit, and I can usually identify a house with attic problems without even going in the house.  The most obvious things to look for on the outside are ice dams, icicles, and patches of unevenly melted snow or frost.  These are all signs of heat loss from the house to the attic space.

Melted_Snow_on_Roof

If I find a Minnesota house with obvious problems on the outside, I look for two conditions in the attic which cause heat loss; lack of insulation and attic bypasses.  Most people readily understand what lack of insulation is, but attic bypasses are generally less understood, and much more time consuming to correct.  An attic bypass is a passageway for heated air to rise in to the attic – insulation won’t fix this.

To understand how attic bypasses work and why insulation doesn’t help, think about wearing a knitted sweater on a cold windy day; the wind will cut right through the sweater, but if you wore a thin windbreaker over the sweater you would be much warmer.  The same principal applies to attics – warm household air will pass right through a foot of fiberglass insulation, but if the air is stopped by a physical barrier (such as the drywall at your ceiling), it won’t pass through the insulation.  According to the Minnesota Department of Commerce, attic bypasses can reduce the overall effectiveness of insulation by as much as 70 percent!  This is why it’s critical to fix attic bypasses before adding more insulation to an attic space.

When I evaluate the insulation in attics, I focus on areas with missing or minimal amounts of insulation.  Missing_and_Insuffient_InsulationAny gaps can drastically reduce the overall effectiveness in the attic.  Attics in new homes should have insulation that provides an insulating value of at least R-38, which equals out to about a foot of fiberglass rolls, or a foot of loose-fill cellulose, or about eighteen inches of loose-fill fiberglass.  If I can see the bottom chords of trusses in an attic, this is an obvious sign that the attic needs more insulation.  While I don’t have any hard and fast rules for my recommendations, I generally say that an insulation level over R-38 is good, between R-19 and R-38 is marginal, and less than R-19 needs correction.

Attic bypasses are much more difficult to identify because they are usually covered by insulation.  While national home inspection standards don’t require inspectors to move insulation, I always make a point of doing this anyways because this is typically the only way to identify them, and they’re important to know about! While bypasses are major sources of heat loss, they can also allow moist household air in to the attic space, which will often condense on the roof boards, creating a frost covered attic space.

Frost_in_Attic Frost_in_Attic_on_Plumbing_Vent Frost_on_Nail_Heads_in_Attic Black_Stains_Around_Nail_Heads_in_Attic

In the summer there is never frost in the attic, but a dead giveaway that frost accumulates in the winter is small black stains around the roofing nails. The frost in attics will form the heaviest around nail heads because they’re the coldest components.  Possibly the worst bypass that I frequently find is a bath fan exhausting in to the attic – these pump warm moist air in to the attic at a ridiculous rate.  Another common place to find bypasses is around the furnace or water heater vent.  I frequently find gaps around the vents that are several feet wide, and these areas are always covered with insulation.  The Minnesota Department of Commerce puts out an excellent brochure on finding bypasses in the attic and how to fix them, which you can download here.

The last thing I look for in an attic space is ventilation.  Attic spaces are almost always unconditioned spaces, so they need to be ventilated to the exterior.  Attic ventilation helps to keep the roof cooler throughout the year, which will help to minimize ice dams in the winter and help prolong the life of the roof in the summer.  While the traditional reason for ventilating an attic space was to prevent condensation in the attic, I’ve read a number of studies lately that say that this may not be as important as we once thought.  I always verify that proper ventilation is in place, and I make suggestions on how to improve ventilation when necessary.

Reuben Saltzman, Structure Tech Home Inspections - Email - Minneapolis Home Inspections

Thursday, December 31, 2009

Insurance Problems Caused By Home Inspection

I received a very odd phone call last year; a customer (I'll call Mary) called to tell me her insurance company was dropping her policy immediately after reading my inspection report for her home.  They told her there were 'too many problems'.  I’ve heard of insurance companies having specific reasons for denying insurance, but never such an ambiguous reason as ‘too many problems'.  I’m wondering if this is going to become a trend.

Mary jokingly told me that she should have hired a crappy inspector, but she was really looking for advice on what to do.  I asked Mary what would have happened if she had not given her insurance company a copy of her report?  Mary said her insurance company requires any house that is over 40 years old to have a professional home inspection performed.  That made me wonder – how do insurance companies define a professional home inspection?  In Minnesota there is no such thing as licensing for home inspectors, so anybody can call themselves a professional home inspector.

Out of curiosity and annoyance with her insurance company, I asked if a one-page document with a few of my recommendations would have sufficed, and she said it probably would have, but it’s too late now.  Once an insurance underwriter makes up their mind, it’s a done deal.  Or so I’ve heard.

I was able to refer Mary to a friend that works for Farmer’s Insurance, and she ended up getting a new policy for her home and car with him the same day (and hopefully saved some money!).  Mary had already tried a couple other companies, but as part of their screening process they asked if she had ever been denied insurance, and she was too worried about getting denied again to go any further in the process.  Farmers Insurance doesn’t ask about that.

While this was a strange situation because there wasn’t anything that specifically made the company deny insurance, there are some specific things that you can look for.  Many insurance companies will require correction of these conditions before insuring the home, or will give you a certain amount of time to have these items fixed:

• A fused electric service.
• Knob and Tube Electrical Wiring.
• Roof problems.  Some insurance companies perform their own drive-by inspection (where they don’t even climb on the roof), and if they don’t like what they see, they’ll require replacement of the roof at the owner’s expense.  There is no arguing with the insurance company about this decision.
• Tree problems.  My friend at Farmers Insurance said that his company is on a big ‘tree kick’, where they get very picky about tree branches being too close to the house.

If you’re in the market for a house, I recommend checking with your insurance agent early in the process for any red flags that you should know about ahead of time.  This quick phone call might save you a lot of hassle in the future.

Reuben Saltzman, Structure Tech Home Inspections - Email - Minneapolis Home Inspections

Wednesday, December 30, 2009

Reasons To Insulate Your Minnesota Home

With the cold weather officially here, it’s a good time to talk about insulation.  This is such a huge topic that I hardly know where to start!  There are so many different aspects to insulation that this will have to take up several blogs.  Today I’ll talk about why it’s important to have a well-insulated home.

DSC02678
Perhaps the most important reason to have a well-insulated home is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.  While a recent survey conducted by Owens-Corning revealed that most Americans believe transportation and industry to be the largest contributors of greenhouse gas emissions, in truth the largest contributor is buildings!  Buildings use 40% of our energy, according to the U.S. Department of Energy.  The number is even higher in Minnesota - 60 to 80 percent! The most cost effective way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions is to better insulate buildings.  Yes, this is even better than driving a hybrid vehicle, but it's certainly not as hip.

P1010043
The most obvious reason to better insulate your home is to reduce your heating and cooling bills – especially here in Minnesota.  Adding insulation to attic spaces is often a project that even unskilled homeowners can tackle, and it doesn’t cost a lot of money. Homeowners will typically see a payback in five to ten years. Adding insulation to poorly insulated walls is also a good thing to do and will surely help to save on heating and cooling costs, but this not as cost effective as adding insulation to an open attic area, as this will often require a professional to blow insulation in to the walls.

P1010055
Arguably the most important reason to better insulate your home is to make it more comfortable. Even if a thermostat says it’s 70 degrees inside the home, poorly insulated walls will make a room feel much colder as the heat from your body radiates out to the relatively cold walls. In older houses with uneven heat, you may even have parts of the house that never warm up enough. I can tell you from experience that insulation makes an incredible difference in the comfort of a home. I live in a one-and-a-half story home with a finished upper level that used to be so cold in the winter that I couldn’t even use it. After re-insulating the upper level last year, I no longer need to heat the upper level! Enough heat rises up from the rest of the house to keep the upper floor so warm that I can shut off all the heat registers and it’s still comfortable.

P1010042
There are many more reasons to properly insulate your home, but I’ll just mention one more that you’re surely aware of if you live in Minnesota; ice dams. While ice dams are a large subject on their own, suffice to say that lack of insulation can lead to large accumulations of ice at the edges of roofs that cause leaks in the home and destroy gutters.

In my next blog I'll talk about how to determine whether more insulation is necessary, and what critical steps need to be taken before adding insulation. Hint: the photos throughout this blog all show homes with major room for improvement!

Reuben Saltzman, Structure Tech Home Inspections - Email - Minneapolis Home Inspections


Related Post: Photos Of Problems With Explanations

Monday, December 28, 2009

Water Heater Replacement Options

When I replaced my first water heater, I was excited to get something larger, more efficient, and maybe even a little sexier.  As it turned out, getting a different type of water heater wasn’t my best option, and now I end up telling my customers the same thing.  If you’re in need of a new water heater, chances are pretty good that you have a 40 – 50 gallon gas water heater, and your best option for replacement will be with the exact same type.

A standard gas water heater is a pretty simple device – there’s a tank that holds water, a burner at the bottom of the tank, and a vent that takes the exhaust gas out of the house through gravity (the warm air rises).  There are several other types of water heaters, and I’m going to list some pros and cons of each type.

Standard Gas - This is what makes up the bulk of water heaters in Minneapolis and Saint Paul – I would estimate 95%.  They have a low cost, they're easy to replace, and they recover hot water relatively quickly.  On the downside, energy is lost by keeping water heated all day.  If you're replacing a standard water heater and there is a problem with the chimney or flue (which usually means it’s not up to code), it can be very expensive to repair the chimney or bring it up to code.

Powervent - These are similar to standard gas water heaters, but instead of the exhaust gases rising up and out of the house, a fan forces the exhaust gases through a plastic pipe out the side of the house.   The biggest advantage is that the exhaust gases don't need to rise up the house through the roof - these water heaters can be vented right through the side of the house.  These are a great option if there are problems with an existing standard water heater flue.  Unfortunately, they cost about twice as much as a standard water heater.  I’ve also noticed that they are frequently installed wrong; I would guess that about 50 – 75 percent of the powervent water heaters that I inspect are incorrectly installed.

Tankless – This type of water heater definitely generates the most interest.  These water heaters only heat the water that you use, so you’re not wasting money by keeping 40 gallons of water hot all day.  They use less energy, take up less space, and provide an endless supply of hot water.  Unfortunately, they cost about three times as much as a standard water heater, and it's very expensive to convert from a standard water heater to a tankless - so much so that getting a payback in energy savings is out of the question.  They also provide a limited volume of hot water; a standard tank will give you all the hot water you want until it's gone, but a tankless water heater produces a limited amount at once.  Click the following link for an in-depth research paper on tankless water heaters.

Electric – Electric water heaters are probably the easiest to install and easiest to replace.  There is no venting required, so they can be installed in small places or in places where it would be difficult or impossible to run a vent.  The biggest downside to electric water heaters is that they take a long time to recover hot water.  Once you’re out of hot water, you’re out for a long time.  I don’t recommend electric water heaters if you have the choice of using gas instead.

Reuben Saltzman, Structure Tech Home Inspections - Email - Minneapolis Home Inspections

Sunday, December 27, 2009

Houses Don't Need CO2 Alarms

There are many common misconceptions about furnaces, water heaters, and carbon monoxide that I hear repeated on a daily basis, and I’d like to clear a few of them up.


False: Carbon Monoxide is also called CO2.  Carbon Monoxide is CO. Carbon Dioxide is CO2.  (Mono = 1, Di = 2)


False: Cracked heat exchangers create CO.  CO is caused by incomplete combustion, period.  A cracked heat exchanger does not create CO.  A heat exchanger is the part of a furnace that transfers heat from the flames to the household air.  A functional heat exchanger keeps the household air and the combustion gases completely separate from each other.  If a furnace has a cracked heat exchanger, the combustion gases can mix with the household air.  It’s usually just a little bit, but this is still unacceptable, and it means the furnace or heat exchanger should be replaced.  The photos below show cracks in heat exchangers (click the photos for full-sized images).


Cracked Heat Exchanger #1 Cracked Heat Exchanger #2 Cracked Heat Exchanger #3 Cracked Heat Exchanger #4


False: Cracked heat exchangers can be fixed.  They can’t be fixed.  The heat exchanger or entire furnace needs to be replaced.



False: High CO levels = cracked heat exchanger.  See above.  We test the CO levels in the flue gas, which has nothing to do with a cracked heat exchanger.  Heat exchangers fail when the metal rusts through or when it cracks.  CO does not cause this.


False: High CO levels in the flue gas mean the furnace is leaking CO.  If there is a high level of CO in the flue gas, there is a potential for the exhaust gases to mix with the household air, or ‘leak’.  One way would be for the exhaust gases to backdraft, which means that instead of rising up and out of the house, they come back down the flue.  The other way would be because of a cracked heat exchanger.  If we find high levels of CO in the flue gas, we recommend immediate repair – it doesn’t matter if the gases are mixing with the household air at the time of the inspection or not, because this condition could potentially change at any time.  Higher CO levels can often be fixed.


False: Backdrafting at a furnace or water heater means CO is coming in to the home.Backdrafting means that exhaust gases are spilling back in to the home, rather than going up the flue.  A properly functioning water heater or furnace will not create CO, so you can’t say CO is coming in to the home unless you test the exhaust gases; we do this at every inspection.  Click here to see a video of me inspecting a furnace.  While backdrafting doesn’t mean CO is coming in to the home, this is still a potentially hazardous situation that requires immediate correction.  Backdrafting has the potential to allow CO in to the home, and will always contain CO2 (carbon dioxide), which can cause sickness and headaches in higher concentrations.

Wrong Term: Hot water heater.  Just 'water heater'.  The heated water that comes out is hot.
To summarize, high levels of CO need to be fixed, cracked heat exchangers need replacement, and backdrafting is never ok.  These three things are all independent, but a combination of these conditions is especially dangerous.  When using these terms, make sure you have them correct.  It makes a difference.


Reuben Saltzman, Structure Tech Home Inspections - Email - Minneapolis Home Inspections


Saturday, December 26, 2009

Gravity Furnaces

If you’re buying a home with a gravity furnace, you should have the furnace replaced.  Gravity furnaces are those huge ‘octopus’ furnaces that can just about fill up a whole room with ductwork.  They are called gravity furnaces because it’s gravity that distributes warm air – the warm air weighs less than cold air, so it rises.  These furnaces don’t have blower fans, and there is little that can go wrong with them.  While I rarely find any safety issues or problems with gravity furnaces, the main reasons to replace them are money, efficiency, and comfort.

The biggest concern for most people is the money it takes to heat a home with a gravity furnace.  Gravity furnaces typically cost about twice as much to operate as a modern forced air furnace, because they are terribly inefficient.  Gravity furnaces just have a huge flame that warms up the air in the ductwork, and all of the exhaust gas that leaves your home through the chimney is wasted heat.  On a gravity furnace, about half the heat generated goes up the chimney, making it about 50% efficient.  Newer furnaces can be as high as 95% efficient.

While money and efficiency go hand-in-hand, I’m listing them separately because replacing your old gravity furnace is also good for the environment; the more efficient your furnace is, the less greenhouse gases get released in to the atmosphere.  Replacing old gravity furnaces is a ‘green’, socially responsible thing to do!

Your home will be much more comfortable with a forced air furnace.  Old gravity furnaces operate by allowing the heated air to rise up the middle of the home, and the cool air falls back down along the outside walls, making the middle of the house warm and the outside walls fairly cold (see diagrams below).  Additionally, with a forced air furnace you’ll now have the option of adding central air conditioning, which is not possible with a gravity furnace because there is no blower fan to distribute the air.

Gravity Furnace Diagram Poorly Located Supply and Return Registers

With all the benefits of replacing a gravity furnace, why don’t more people do it?  Cost.  A gravity furnace and the ductwork for a gravity furnace will almost always contain asbestos.  An asbestos abatement contractor will need to remove the old furnace, which obviously drives up the cost of the replacement.  The ductwork will also need to be modified, because the new furnace should have smaller supply ducts going to the outside walls, and larger return ducts on the inside walls.  This is the opposite of how gravity furnaces are designed to work.

Besides all of the logical explanations for replacing or not replacing a gravity furnace, you should also consider the emotional aspects; most home buyers that I work with are very nervous about buying homes with gravity furnaces.   I always wonder how many potential buyers already passed on a home just because they were worried about the gravity furnace!

Reuben Saltzman, Structure Tech Home Inspections - Email - Minneapolis Home Inspections

Monday, December 21, 2009

Converting Two-Prong Outlets

A common question I get about older homes is whether two-prong outlets can safely be changed over to three-prong outlets.  Most home buyers today don’t want to be stuck with two-prong outlets throughout the house.  Two-prong outlets can always be changed to three-prong, and this can be accomplished a few different ways.  Today I’ll give a very brief explanation of what the third prong is for, and I’ll discuss a few ways to convert to a three prong outlet.  I didn’t consult an attorney before writing this article, so I feel like I should add a disclaimer before giving any electrical how-to advice: Don’t do any of this work if you’re not qualified.  This is only an overview.


The third prong on an outlet is commonly referred to as 'the ground’, and it provides an alternate path for electricity that may stray from an appliance or product.  This is an important safety feature that has been required since 1962, which minimizes the risk of electric shock, and allows surge protectors to
protect your electrical equipment, such as televisions, computers, stereos, and other devices.

The ideal way to upgrade a two prong outlet is to install a three prong outlet that has a continuous electrical path back to the panel.  If the outlet is installed in a metal box, and that metal box has metal conduit all the way back to the panel, this will probably be pretty easy to do.  To test this, you can use an inexpensive pig-tail electrical tester, which is available at any hardware store for about two dollars.  With the circuit energized, touch one end of the tester to the hot wire, which should go to the smaller slot on the outlet, and one end of the tester to the electrical box  (see photo below left).  If the tester lights up, the box is grounded.  Now all you need to do is attach a bare copper wire to the box, and use this as the ground wire for a three prong outlet (see photo below right).
Testing For Ground on a Two-Prong Outlet Grounding a three-prong outlet to a box
If you perform the test with a pig-tail tester and the light doesn’t light up when you touch the hot wire to the box, the box is not grounded (or you’re not touching a hot wire).  In this case, you could run a ground wire back to the panel, or you could replace your two-prong outlet with a GFCI outlet.  A GFCI outlet provides the best possible protection against shocks, but without a ground wire, this outlet will not provide any protection for your electrical equipment.  A surge protector plugged in to an ungrounded outlet will do nothing, and you could fry your new plasma TV.  You will need to add a sticker to the GFCI outlet that reads “No Equipment Ground” – this sticker comes with every GFCI outlet.
Testing for ground at a cover plate
What about two-prong to three-prong adapters?  These can only be safely used on a groundedtwo-prong outlet.  A pig-tail tester will light up on a grounded two-prong outlet if you touch one lead to the smaller slot on the outlet, and the other lead to the screw in the middle of the outlet.
Unsafe Adapter Use Safe Adapter Use
If this is the case, you can safely use a two-prong to three-prong adapter, as long as you secure it to the outlet with the cover plate screw.  Any other use of a two-prong adapter is unsafe.

Reuben Saltzman, Structure Tech Home Inspections - Email - Minneapolis Home Inspections